Independent Judgment for Complex Valuation
Independent Judgment for Complex Valuation

Trademarks, trade names, brands, and other marketing-related intangible assets can contribute significantly to enterprise value through customer recognition, purchasing decisions, pricing, market access, reputation, and competitive position.
However, the existence of a registered trademark or recognizable name does not by itself establish economic value.
Alpha Consulting Group provides independent trademark, brand, and marketing intangible valuation for M&A, PPA, licensing, restructuring, transfer pricing, ownership transactions, and other business purposes.
A trademark is a legal right. A brand represents a broader economic relationship involving market recognition, customer experience, reputation, products, services, and continuing commercial activity.
Depending upon the valuation purpose, marketing-related intangible assets may include:
The analysis should begin by identifying the specific asset, legal rights, economic benefits, and commercial context being valued.
A brand should not be valued as though it were economically detached from the business that creates, supports, protects, and commercially exploits it.
Brand value may depend upon:
The economic benefits associated with the brand must therefore be distinguished from returns attributable to other contributing functions and assets.
A useful analytical framework considers the functions, assets, and risks associated with creating and maintaining the marketing intangible.
Functions
Who develops, promotes, maintains, protects, and commercially exploits the brand?
Assets
What products, technology, distribution, customer relationships, workforce, contracts, and other assets support those functions?
Risks
Who bears market, reputational, product, competitive, regulatory, and commercial risks?
Economic Benefits
Does the brand contribute to pricing, customer preference, recurring revenue, market penetration, customer retention, or other economic benefits?
This analysis helps distinguish the economic contribution of the brand from the economics of the enterprise as a whole.
A recognizable name can have substantial commercial importance, but recognition alone does not establish economic value.
A brand may have strong recognition but limited pricing power, declining market share, substantial required marketing expenditures, weak customer retention, or exposure to changing customer preferences.
Conversely, a specialized brand with limited general public recognition may have substantial economic value within a particular industry or customer market.
The relevant question is not simply how well known the brand is, but what economic benefits and returns are reasonably attributable to it.
Corporate brands present a particularly challenging valuation question because the brand may be closely integrated with the enterprise itself.
A corporate brand may influence:
The analytical issue is determining which economic benefits can reasonably be attributed to the corporate brand and which arise from the combined functions, assets, capabilities, investment, and risks of the enterprise.
The closer the brand is integrated with the enterprise, the more important it becomes to distinguish brand-related economic benefits from enterprise value itself.
A highly recognized corporate brand should not automatically be assigned the residual economic value of the business simply because the brand is prominent.
Trademarks may have renewable legal rights, but indefinite legal life does not automatically mean indefinite economic value.
Economic life may be affected by:
Brands also require continuing support.
Advertising, product quality, distribution, customer service, innovation, and other activities may be necessary to sustain expected economic benefits.
An important valuation question is therefore:
What continuing investment is required to maintain the expected economic benefits and returns?
Brand valuation has produced numerous methods and analytical models, reflecting the different ways in which brands can create economic benefits.
The appropriate methodology depends upon the nature of the brand, rights being valued, available evidence, valuation purpose, and the economic mechanism through which the brand contributes to the business.
Analysis may draw upon income, market, cost, royalty, incremental benefit, brand-strength, and other economic evidence where appropriate. Multiple indicators may also be considered and reconciled to the economics of the enterprise.
Methodology does not determine value. Economics determines which methodology is meaningful.
The objective is not to select a model first and then force the brand into it. The objective is to understand how the brand creates economic benefits and returns, and then determine which methodology or combination of evidence best measures those benefits.
Trademarks and brands are frequently licensed, but a royalty rate should not be viewed independently from the underlying economics of the business.
A licensing analysis may consider:
The economics of the license should be consistent with the rights transferred and the economic benefits reasonably available to the parties.
A particular owner may obtain additional benefits from a brand because of its existing products, distribution, customer base, technology, geographic reach, or strategic capabilities.
Those benefits may differ from those available to independent parties or market participants.
The analysis should therefore distinguish market or arm’s-length economic benefits from entity-specific strategic benefits when required by the valuation purpose.
Entity-specific benefits may contribute to investment value without necessarily representing fair value or arm’s-length value.
Valuation may arise in connection with:
The appropriate analysis depends upon the specific rights, economic benefits, transaction, parties, and valuation purpose.
A brand can be an important contributor to enterprise value without representing the entire value of the business.
Enterprise economics may simultaneously depend upon products, technology, customer relationships, distribution, workforce, contracts, physical assets, capital, management, and continuing investment.
A supportable valuation therefore considers the benefits attributable to the brand while recognizing the contributions of these other assets and activities.
The same enterprise economic benefit cannot independently be attributed to the brand and every other contributing asset.
Enterprise value therefore provides an important point of reconciliation when evaluating the reasonableness of brand value.
Brand valuation requires more than identifying a recognizable name, selecting a royalty rate, or applying a predetermined model.
A useful analytical progression is:
Brand & rights → functions and supporting assets → risks and continuing investment → economic life → economic benefits and returns → value
The purpose is to understand how the brand participates in the economics of the business and select valuation evidence consistent with those economics.
Methodology does not determine value. Economics determines which methodology is meaningful.
Alpha Consulting Group provides independent trademark, brand, and marketing intangible valuation for M&A, PPA, licensing, restructuring, transfer pricing, and other business purposes.
Contact us to discuss the asset, economic rights, valuation purpose, and appropriate scope of analysis.
Copyright © 2020 AlphaConsultingUS.com - Valuation Economics: Purchase Price Allocation (PPA), IP/Intangible Assets, Transfer Pricing Study, Enterprise & Infrastructure, Commercial Reasonableness for Project Investment.
All Rights Reserved.
CVA (Certified Business Valuation Analyst), ASA (Accredited Senior Appraiser), CCIM (Certified Commercial Investment Member), CM&AA (Certified M&A Advisor), MAFF (Master Analyst in Financial Forensics). (Certified General Real Estate Appraiser in States of CA, VA, FL, NV, TX, OR, WA, GA, HI)
한미 FDI 실사 자문 가치평가